Andoni Iraola believes Ryan Gravenberch’s second-half red card completely changed Liverpool’s Premier League clash with Manchester City, arguing that his side had been the better team before being reduced to 10 men in Sunday’s 3-0 defeat at Anfield.
Liverpool and City were locked at 0-0 after 62 minutes when Gravenberch received his second yellow card. Manchester City then took control, with Erling Haaland, Jeremy Doku and Rayan Cherki scoring to turn a tightly contested match into a convincing victory for the visitors.
The result represented Liverpool’s first Premier League defeat of the season, while Manchester City extended their perfect league start to six victories from six matches. City finished the weekend three points clear of Arsenal at the top, while Liverpool dropped to ninth.
For Iraola, however, the final score did not accurately describe the first hour of the contest.
He felt Liverpool had matched and, for significant periods, outperformed City before Gravenberch’s dismissal altered the numerical and tactical balance.
Supporters can follow the Reds throughout the season through SoccerMatchToday’s Liverpool team, with the wider campaign covered in the Premier League section.
Iraola Says Liverpool Played Two Different Matches
Iraola’s assessment was built around one clear dividing point.
Before the sending-off, he believed Liverpool were competing on at least equal terms with Manchester City.
After it, the game became fundamentally different.
The Liverpool head coach said there had effectively been “two different games”, one before Gravenberch’s dismissal and another after it. He felt his players were performing better during the opening 62 minutes before City exploited their numerical advantage.
That is an important distinction when assessing the 3-0 scoreline.
Manchester City unquestionably deserved credit for taking advantage once Liverpool went down to 10.
But Liverpool had not spent the opening hour being dominated.
They had pressed aggressively, competed strongly in duels and used the intensity inside Anfield to make life uncomfortable for the league leaders.
Only after the red card did the match become increasingly one-sided.
Ryan Gravenberch’s Red Card Changed Everything
Gravenberch’s dismissal was the decisive moment.
The Netherlands midfielder had already been booked when he committed the challenge that produced his second yellow card in the 62nd minute.
That left Liverpool with more than half an hour to survive against a City side possessing some of the most dangerous attacking players in Europe.
The task quickly became much more difficult.
Liverpool could no longer press with the same aggression.
Their midfield coverage changed.
Spaces began opening between defensive lines.
And City could circulate possession knowing Liverpool had one fewer player available to close passing lanes.
Haaland eventually made the advantage count.
Once City scored the opener, Liverpool were forced to chase the match despite their numerical disadvantage.
That created even more room for Doku and Cherki.
Iraola Disagreed With Gravenberch’s First Booking
The Liverpool coach’s strongest criticism concerned Gravenberch’s first yellow card, rather than the second.
Iraola argued that the initial challenge was too minor to justify a caution.
He also questioned why referee Elliot Anderson initially allowed play to continue before eventually returning to show the card, particularly because the incident occurred around midfield with Liverpool well organised defensively.
That matters because without the first yellow, Gravenberch’s later challenge would not have resulted in dismissal.
From Iraola’s perspective, the referee effectively created the conditions for the later red card by being too severe early in the game.
His frustration was therefore less about denying that Gravenberch committed another bookable offence later and more about whether the midfielder should have been carrying a yellow card in the first place.
Iraola Also Questioned Early Refereeing Decisions
Gravenberch was not the only Liverpool player booked early.
Ronald Araújo also received a yellow card after protesting a decision.
Iraola accepted that the laws allow referees to punish dissent but suggested officials will need to maintain that same strict standard consistently throughout the season if they choose to apply it so aggressively.
The concern for a coach is tactical as much as disciplinary.
An early yellow card changes how defenders approach duels.
A full-back or centre-back who is booked inside the opening stages cannot defend with exactly the same freedom for the remainder of the match.
Against players such as Doku and Haaland, that can become particularly significant.
Iraola therefore felt Liverpool were operating under disciplinary pressure before the match had properly developed.
Liverpool Had Been Growing Into the Game
The timing of the dismissal made the outcome even more frustrating for Liverpool.
Iraola believed his side were approaching their strongest period of the match when they lost Gravenberch.
Liverpool had survived City’s early threat and gradually increased their own attacking pressure.
The Anfield crowd was responding.
The intensity was increasing.
And the home side were beginning to find more promising positions.
Iraola said Liverpool were probably enjoying their best spell when the red card arrived.
That is why he resisted judging the entire performance through the final score.
Three goals conceded usually suggest a comprehensive defeat.
His interpretation is that Liverpool were competitive for an hour before a major match event changed everything.
Manchester City Punished Liverpool Ruthlessly
That should not reduce the credit due to Manchester City.
Elite teams are defined partly by how efficiently they exploit favourable situations.
City did exactly that.
After Liverpool went down to 10 men, they increased possession, moved the ball faster and forced Iraola’s players deeper.
Erling Haaland opened the scoring, continuing his remarkable start to the season.
Jeremy Doku then produced an outstanding strike to double the advantage.
Rayan Cherki completed the scoring, giving City a 3-0 victory at one of the Premier League’s most difficult away grounds.
The margin was severe for Liverpool.
The efficiency was typical of the City.
Once the opening goal arrived, they never allowed the home side a realistic route back.
Haaland Again Makes the Difference
Haaland inevitably became central to the result.
Liverpool had managed to keep the Norwegian quiet while the match remained 11 against 11.
Once the balance changed, City began creating the space he thrives on.
His movement became harder to track.
Liverpool’s defenders had to cover larger areas.
And eventually Haaland found the breakthrough.
The goal reinforced City’s ability to turn tight matches through one decisive attacking moment.
Liverpool now have to regroup quickly, while City continue setting the early pace at the top of the Premier League.
SoccerMatchToday readers can check upcoming matches through the Liverpool fixtures, and review recent performances through Liverpool results.
Doku and Cherki Finish Liverpool Off
Once City went ahead, Iraola faced an extremely difficult decision.
Liverpool could remain compact and attempt to keep the deficit at one.
Or they could take greater risks in search of an equaliser.
At Anfield, with the crowd demanding a response, Liverpool naturally attempted to push forward.
City took advantage.
Doku’s goal highlighted the winger’s individual quality, while Cherki’s late strike completed a result that looked much more comfortable than the contest had during the opening hour.
That is one of the dangers of playing a technically gifted side with 10 men.
Defending deeper can surrender control.
Attacking more aggressively creates open spaces.
Neither option is attractive.
City had enough quality to exploit both.
Iraola Still Praised Liverpool’s Players
Despite losing heavily, Iraola resisted criticising the attitude of his squad.
He felt Liverpool’s players had given everything.
That distinction is important.
A 3-0 home defeat can often trigger questions about effort, commitment or intensity.
Iraola did not see those as Liverpool’s problems.
He praised the competitiveness of his team and pointed towards the quality of their performance while the sides had equal numbers.
For the coach, the lesson appears to be about maintaining discipline and avoiding situations that expose the team rather than questioning whether the players worked hard enough.
That provides a more constructive starting point for the next match.
Anfield Gave Liverpool a Major Advantage
Iraola was particularly impressed by the supporters.
The atmosphere at Anfield had been intense even before kick-off.
Manchester City arrived for their first match since an independent commission found the club guilty of 114 Premier League financial-rule breaches, findings City deny and are appealing.
The visitors were greeted with loud boos, hostile chants and banners from Liverpool supporters.
Iraola felt that atmosphere gave Liverpool a genuine competitive advantage.
He described Anfield as a major reason his team were able to play with such intensity before the red card.
That is particularly relevant because Liverpool’s home environment has historically been one of the club’s greatest strengths.
Iraola appears determined to ensure that remains true under his management.
City Handled an Extremely Hostile Atmosphere
Manchester City’s response also deserves recognition.
The controversy surrounding their financial-rule case created an unusual environment.
Liverpool supporters had organised a particularly hostile reception, and security surrounding City’s arrival was increased.
Rather than allowing that environment to disrupt them, City remained composed.
Manager Enzo Maresca had told his players before the match that the best response to the noise surrounding the club was to create their own through winning football matches.
The 3-0 result gave him exactly that.
City’s ability to maintain concentration amid the atmosphere was another factor separating the teams once Liverpool were reduced to 10.
Liverpool Were Missing Alexander Isak and Cody Gakpo
Iraola also entered the match without two significant attacking options.
Alexander Isak and Cody Gakpo were both unavailable after suffering injuries while on international duty.
Isak had sustained a minor thigh problem with Sweden, while Gakpo returned from Netherlands duty with an ankle injury.
Their absence reduced Liverpool’s attacking flexibility.
Isak had been in particularly strong form, scoring four times in his opening five league appearances.
Against Manchester City, where attacking opportunities can be limited, losing a forward capable of finishing low-volume chances was significant.
It would be inaccurate to present those injuries as the reason Liverpool lost.
But they unquestionably reduced Iraola’s options, especially once the game state changed.
Liverpool Also Have a Dominik Szoboszlai Fitness Concern
The defeat produced another concern.
Iraola revealed after the match that Dominik Szoboszlai had returned from international duty with tightness and an overload.
Liverpool attempted to manage his workload during training, but the midfielder was still experiencing a minor physical issue.
The timing is inconvenient.
Liverpool face a demanding run of fixtures and are due to travel to Austria only days after the Manchester City game.
Iraola acknowledged that recovering injured players could be difficult given the schedule.
The issue does not necessarily mean Szoboszlai faces a significant spell out.
But Liverpool will need to monitor him closely.
Liverpool’s Schedule Leaves Little Time to Recover
One of the challenges of modern elite football is that disappointing results cannot be processed for very long.
Liverpool have another European assignment almost immediately.
That means recovery becomes both physical and psychological.
Players who spent more than half an hour defending against City with 10 men will have expended significant energy.
Others returned from international duty carrying minor physical problems.
And Liverpool’s coaching staff must now prepare another tactical plan almost immediately.
Iraola referenced four matches in 10 days, highlighting the intensity of the current period.
Squad depth will therefore matter.
The Result Should Not Be Dismissed Completely Because of the Red Card
There is also a danger in explaining everything through Gravenberch’s dismissal.
The red card unquestionably changed the match.
But Liverpool still need to examine why City were able to score three times afterwards.
Strong teams occasionally have to survive periods with 10 men.
That requires compactness, discipline and intelligent game management.
Liverpool did not manage that successfully.
Once Haaland scored, their resistance deteriorated quickly.
That provides Iraola with useful information.
The lesson should not simply be:
avoid red cards.
It should also be:
manage adversity better when matches go wrong.
That could become important later in the season.
Iraola’s Liverpool Are Still Developing
The defeat also needs to be placed within the broader context of Iraola’s first season in charge.
Liverpool are adapting to a different coach and a different tactical structure.
There have been major squad changes.
New players are still adjusting.
And Iraola is still learning exactly which combinations work best at the highest level.
Sunday provided one of the clearest tests so far.
Manchester City currently set the benchmark.
For an hour, Liverpool competed strongly.
After the red card, the gap became obvious.
Both parts of the match are useful for understanding where Iraola’s team currently stands.
Liverpool Suffer First League Defeat of the Season
One positive is that Liverpool had reached this stage of the campaign unbeaten in the Premier League.
Manchester City inflicted their first league defeat.
Reuters reported that the result left Liverpool ninth in the table, while City maintained their perfect record and moved three points ahead of Arsenal.
Six matches is still a small portion of a Premier League season.
Liverpool’s position can change quickly.
But they cannot afford to allow the defeat to become the beginning of a poor run.
The upcoming schedule gives them an immediate opportunity to respond.
For the current league picture, readers can check SoccerMatchToday’s Premier League standings.
Brentford Become Liverpool’s Next Premier League Test
Liverpool’s next Premier League fixture is away to Brentford on October 17.
That game now carries additional significance.
A strong response would allow Iraola to present the City defeat as a match transformed by one isolated incident.
Another poor result would create deeper questions.
Brentford will also pose a different tactical challenge.
Liverpool are unlikely to face exactly the same possession dominance that City can produce.
Instead, they may need to control more of the match themselves and break down a team prepared to defend compactly and attack quickly in transition.
That requires a different type of performance.
Gravenberch’s Suspension Creates Another Midfield Problem
The red card also has consequences beyond Sunday.
Because Gravenberch was dismissed after receiving two yellow cards, Liverpool must now prepare without him for the next domestic fixture.
That creates another selection problem at a time when Szoboszlai’s fitness is uncertain.
Iraola may need to adjust the midfield structure.
He could choose a more conservative combination.
He could alter the pressing responsibilities.
Or he could use the suspension as an opportunity to give another midfielder greater responsibility.
How Liverpool replace Gravenberch will become one of the main tactical questions before Brentford.
City Continue Their Perfect Premier League Start
For Manchester City, the picture could hardly be more different on the pitch.
They have now won all six of their Premier League matches this season.
Enzo Maresca became only the fourth manager to win his first six Premier League matches.
That achievement is particularly notable given the enormous off-field uncertainty surrounding the club.
City are appealing the independent commission’s findings relating to financial-rule breaches.
The possible sanctions remain unresolved.
Yet the football team has continued winning.
That ability to separate the sporting situation from the regulatory process has been one of the defining features of their season so far.
Iraola’s Assessment Is Understandable, but Liverpool Must Move On
The Liverpool coach is justified in seeing the red card as the decisive moment.
The match was goalless.
Liverpool were competitive.
The crowd was engaged.
Then Gravenberch was dismissed.
City scored three times afterwards.
Those are the basic facts.
But the next stage is more important than explaining the defeat.
Iraola must make sure Liverpool learn from it.
Discipline needs to improve.
The team needs to manage difficult match states better.
And players returning from injuries or international duty must be carefully handled through a demanding fixture run.
Liverpool’s 3-0 Defeat Was More Complicated Than the Scoreline Suggests
A simple reading says Manchester City travelled to Anfield and comfortably won 3-0.
The match itself was more nuanced.
Liverpool competed strongly for 62 minutes.
Iraola believed his team were the better side during that period.
Then Ryan Gravenberch received a second yellow card.
From there, Manchester City’s quality and numerical advantage became decisive.
Haaland scored.
Doku scored.
Cherki scored.
And Liverpool were left with a heavy defeat that did not reflect how close the game had been before the dismissal.
Iraola can reasonably take positives from the opening hour.
He can also reasonably feel frustrated by the first yellow card shown to Gravenberch.
But football offers little time for extended debate.
Liverpool must recover physically, manage their growing injury concerns and ensure one disappointing afternoon does not become something more damaging.
Their season will ultimately be judged not by how they lost to Manchester City, but by how they respond.
For ongoing coverage, SoccerMatchToday provides Liverpool fixtures, Liverpool results and live football scores across supported competitions.
